- Ananelus, 37-36 BC
- Aristobulus III, 36 BC *He was the last of the Hasmoneans; brother in law to Herod)
- Ananelus (restored), 36-30 BC
- Joshua ben Fabus, 30-23 BC (7 yrs)
- Simon ben Boethus, 23-5 BC (28 yrs)
- Herod's father in law, from an Alexandrian family
- Matthias ben Theophilus, 5-4 BC
- Joazar ben Boethus, 4 BC
- Eleazar ben Boethus, 4-3 BC
- Joshua ben Sie, 3 BC - ?
- Joazar ben Boethus (restored), ? - 6 AD
- Ananus ben Seth, 6-15 (9yrs) by Quirinius
- first appointed by Roman governor
- Ishmael ben Fabus (Phiabi), 15-16
- Eleazar ben Ananus, 16-17
- Simon ben Camithus, 17-18
- Joseph ben Caiaphas, 18-36 (18 yrs) by Valerius Gratus
- Ananus' son in law, presided over trial of Jesus
- Jonathan ben Ananus, 36-37
- Theophilus ben Ananus, 37-41
- Simon Cantatheras ben Boethus, 41-43
- Matthias ben Ananus, 43
- Elioneus ben Simon Cantatheras, 43-44